From chef knives to kitchen shears, there’s a wide variety of knives out there. So which are worth buying? Here is the comparison between a ceramic knife vs steel knife.
Ceramic knives and stainless steel knives are both types of knives that have been used for a very long time. These two materials are commonly used for making kitchen utensils and knives. However, there are some benefits of ceramic knives over steel knives and vice versa. There are also some advantages of stainless steel knives over ceramic knives and vice versa.
It’s important to understand that knives are a necessity in every kitchen and that a good knife can make cooking easier and more enjoyable. But there are many different kinds of knives out there. Some are more expensive than others, but which one is better? Today we’re going to compare the two most common types of knives which is ceramic knife vs steel knife.
- Ceramic Vs Steel Knife:
- What Is A Ceramic Knife?
- Blade & Sharpness:
- The Ceramic Knife Blade:
- What Is A Steel Knife?
- Blade & Sharpness:
- Steel Knife Blade:
- Extraordinary Features Between Ceramic Knife vs Steel knife:
- Frequently Asked Questions:
Ceramic Vs Steel Knife:
The main difference between ceramic and steel knives is their material, construction, and hardness. Both stainless steel and ceramic blade have vast differences, including hardness, sharpness, environmental resistance, weight, and maintenance.
This article compared ceramic vs steel knife based on their material, design, sharpness, maintenance property, and corrosion resistance. This comparison is based upon our personal experience and the top chef’s recommendation. Both ceramic and steel material is commonly used for making kitchen utensils and knives.
Both have exceptional performance in the kitchen; however, there also are some pros and cons related to them that you need to know. Let’s take a look at the benefit and disadvantages of each knife.
|Durability||Extra Durable||Less Durable|
|Sharpness Need||No Need Of Frequent Sharpening||Need Frequent Sharpening|
|Affect On Food Taste||Don’t Affect At All||Limited Affect|
What Is A Ceramic Knife?
The main thing for which ceramic knives are famous is their hardness, durability, and toughness. The second most important feature of the ceramic blade material is that it restricts the transfer of the food taste and keeps the original taste of the food.
Ceramic material is a very dense and hard material with tiny pores on its surface. Despite having much hardness and strength of the material, some people get confused with the weight of the knife, but it is very lightweight compared to steel material.
These knives are made of both ceramic and Zirconium oxide. One needs to dry press it in order for a solid material to form. After that, one needs to sharpen it and then a sharp ceramic blade can be in use. When measured on a Mohs scale, the hardness is at eight-point-five. This is why the ceramic is second to diamonds for its hardness.
Here are some of the features related to the ceramics knives:
Blade & Sharpness:
When it comes to a knife being made of ceramic, they are known for being very hard. If you don’t know, ceramic is one of the hardest materials. It’s the second on the list, in fact. It means that if you buy a ceramic knife, you won’t have to worry about it becoming dull quickly. It is extremely sharp and will stay so for a very long time. If it ever comes down that you need to sharpen the knife, you can get sharpening for free most of the time.
Generally, the edges of ceramic knives aren’t so durable. That is because ceramic knives are more likely to shatter. However, when it comes to rust, it’s expected ceramic knives to last longer in that category. However, these days it is possible to purchase a stainless steel knife in which case a steel knife wins partially here.
Ceramic knives are a lot more lightweight than steel knives. This makes them ideal for anyone because it means these knives do not cause back pain while cutting. They will be able to handle these knives with incredible ease no matter how strong you are or not.
Ceramic knives are ideal for cutting meat, bread, vegetables, and also for fruit. They are incredibly sharp so you will be able to cut through these items with ease and accuracy. However, they are not generally very versatile. They only have one intended usege and have more or less difficulty completing different tasks that aren’t intended.
The Ceramic Knife Blade:
You might think everything ceramic has something to do with clay, but ceramic knives are exceptions to that. The ceramic blades on these knives are made from oxidized zirconia. This agent is dry-pressed and fired into a fine powder that is then forged into a very tough ceramic knife. Thus, the toughness of a ceramic knife is way higher than an average steel blade.
In putting the core strength in figures, when fully forged, a ceramic blade has a toughness rate of 8.5, which is very close to the core strength of a diamond having 10. An average steel blade comes with a rate of 4 to 6, and it could be more, depending on the steel type. Thus, a ceramic blade is quite strong and tougher than most steel knives.
Ceramic knives have become popular because of their superior sharpness and hardness. They can cut through bones and boneless meats easily. You don’t need to worry about damaging your knife as they can be used repeatedly without breaking down.
These ceramic blades come in different types of knives. Thus, you can get them as a paring knife, a cleaver, a Santoku, a chef’s knife, and so many other types of knives. However, like every other form of ceramic, a ceramic blade is brittle and breakable. This means it can break when you drop it, and it can chip when used on harder materials.
A ceramic knife is not ideal for use when deboning meat or cutting through bones. You cannot also use it to cut through frozen food as this can chip the edge and might even crack the knife.
What Is A Steel Knife?
Steel knives are versatile for professional and home kitchens due to their sharpness, light weight, flexibility, and affordable prices. Depending on their blade shape, they can perform various activities like cutting, slicing, chopping, trimming, and carving.
Stainless steel knives are less hard, but if you want an extra harder and tough knife, you can choose a high carbon stainless steel knife for that purpose. Moreover, steel knives use modern technologies and features for hardening, sharpening, and reliability.
Steel knives are easier and cheaper to sharpen by several methods like the whetstone, steel rod, and any sharpening tool, while on the other hand, the ceramic knife can only be sharped by a diamond dust coated wheel. They are more versatile as most kitchen chef knives are made from steel. The only hazard involved is corrosion and rust in steel knives due to not taking care of after use.
It is an ergonomic and elegant steel knife designed for professional chefs, ordinary persons, and food caterers. It is a multipurpose knife perfect for preparing any dishes from meat, fruits, and vegetables. The knife is solid and durable enough for performing any heavy-duty tasks.
It is made from high-quality German stainless steel, which is highly corrosion-resistant. The knife featured the most rigid construction with an 8” large blade, considered perfect for the professional kitchen.
The Materials used to make a steel knife are carbon, titanium, iron and even more materials. They are either a combination of all of them or just a few. With a steel knife, one can carve, serrating, pairing etc.
Here are some of the necessary points to keep in mind.
Blade & Sharpness:
Steel knives are not as sharp as their ceramic counterpart. However, they can be used to slice any sort of food including hard food. They can also be designed to have stainless steel, which comes close to the sharpness of a ceramic knife. Steel is a much softer material in comparison to ceramic. That’s why it dulls more often and requires sharpening frequently.
When it comes to durability, steel knives generally can last you for a very long time. They can be in your kitchen for quite some time. Sharpening them regularly doesn’t mean they aren’t durable. Dropping them doesn’t break them so you don’t need to be too careful with them unlike with ceramic knives.
Steel knives are definitely heavier than ceramic ones. So, you may need a little bit of strength in your arms to use them. However, steel knives do get the job done so it isn’t that big of a problem. On top of that, there is a good balance to handle due to the weight. This makes the cutting experience a lot more efficient.
Steel knives are a lot more versatile than ceramic ones. They can cut through almost any food and this includes hard ones. There are many different types of steel knives that one can purchase for different purposes.
It is mostly up to your needs and your cooking style and which kind of steel knife you’re going to go for. Luckily, there are many types and you can feel free to choose whichever you please. You will notice that every one of them has a different purpose. There are many different components that make the steel knife as well and that’s one of the reasons why they are so versatile.
Steel Knife Blade:
As mentioned earlier, steel is the widely popular traditional material used in making knife blades. Although there are various types of steel with varying core strength and advantages. You will find carbon steel, sharp edge steel, stainless steel, and high-speed steel all under the steel materials for making great steel blades.
Steel isn’t just popular for no reason. Professionals have identified the non-brittle and tough attribute of steel that gives it an extreme level of versatility over the years. They are dense and strong, making them resistant to wear and giving them excellent edge retention.
With a steel blade, you can cut through bones, frozen food, fruits, vegetables, and all manners of food without the fear of your blade chipping or the knife breaking. Unlike the ceramic blade, and depending on storage and environment, steel knives are more susceptible to rust which is one of the trade-offs for this material. On a good note, steel knives are easier to sharpen than ceramic knives.
Extraordinary Features Between Ceramic Knife vs Steel knife:
Which, between ceramic knife blade vs steel, best suits your everyday kitchen or general food preparation needs? We have drawn out their standout features to help you decide.
Both ceramic blades and steel blades can deliver the same level of sharpness and precision cutting. The concern is about edge retention and how to sharpen the edges. Sharpening a ceramic knife is quite tricky and needs a special sharpener with diamond abrasives to get the edge in shape. Meanwhile, a regular sharpening stone is good enough to do the trick on steel blades. Overall, a ceramic blade is 10x sharper than steel.
It is easy to confuse the toughness of a ceramic knife blade to meaning very hard and unbreakable. Ceramic knives aren’t unbreakable as they can break up when they are hit against equally strong materials because of their brittleness. However, steel blades are pretty indestructible.
A steel knife is more versatile than a ceramic blade in cutting through most kitchen stuff. Ceramic blades are only great with soft stuff, and as such, they do not come in certain types of knives.
Frequently Asked Questions:
How To Clean A Steel Knife?
Steel knives can be cleaned well with just a hand wash, but they are not recommended for dishwashers as there is always a fear of damaging knife edges. You can place the knife in a warm water bowl for 5 to 10 minutes, and then use your hands to easily clean it.
Are ceramic blades worth it?
For those who prefer a more traditional blade, it’s true that ceramic blades don’t cut as fast or smoothly as steel blades. But they do provide a smooth cut, and that’s why so many people prefer them. Other people claim they don’t provide enough feedback – well, maybe that’s because they use the stagger tooth crunch blade.
What Are Ceramic Knives Made Of?
The most widely used type of ceramic knife is Zirconium Dioxide Ceramic. This type of knife is made from a solid substance that is heated to extreme temperatures in order to harden the blade. Only a diamond-coated steel wheel can hone the blade.
Are ceramic or steel blades better?
Ceramic blades have a hardness of 8.2, and steel blades have about 4-6. They stay sharper, longer – One of the biggest benefits of owning a ceramic blade is its tendency to stay sharper for extended periods compared to its steel counterparts.
If you’re wondering which one is better in ceramic knife vs steel knife? Well, it certainly depends on what you need a knife for. Steel knives are generally more versatile and are more durable, so if you’re not completely sure, steel knives provide a wide range of options. Ceramic knives, on the other hand, are more narrow in their versatility and more prone to break.
Both blades are quite affordable and can help you to easily and quickly cut through different types of food. However, if you are looking for an extremely strong blade that is known to be able to handle even the most demanding cutting tasks in the kitchen, you should go for a more reliable steel knife instead.